# Verification status

| Artifact | Status | Required verification |
|---|---|---|
| Context source integrity | internally accepted | all 12 SHA-256 checks pass |
| Context audit | internally accepted | source coverage and contradiction checks pass |
| Claim register | internally accepted | 78 claims; source-state and program-evidence taxonomies separated |
| Terminology | internally accepted | context and literature usage checked |
| Prior-art map | internally accepted | 65 primary/authoritative records close |
| Formalization roadmap | internally accepted | language boundaries, invariants, and fixture assumptions close |
| Implementation roadmap | internally accepted | 19 crates, 96 strictly descending dependency edges, slices 0–14 |
| Benchmark plan | internally accepted | baselines, controls, source capture, statistics, and falsification close |
| Paper manifest | internally accepted | P1–P18 plus synthesis contracts complete |
| Dependency graph | internally accepted | exact 19-node, 70-edge acyclic projection |
| Synthesis outline | internally accepted | all five synthesis questions covered |
| Repository and website plan | internally accepted | structure and later quality gates covered |
| Knowledge base | internally accepted | CR/B/P/formal/SYS/ART/BL closure passes |
| README | internally accepted | final evidence boundary, all 19 paper links, repository URL, and production website URL verified |
| CITATION.cff | internally accepted | parses as YAML and validates against the official CFF 1.2.0 JSON schema |
| P1 evidence contract | internally accepted | hypothesis, falsification, artifact, and review gates explicit |
| P1 research dossiers | internally accepted | literature, formal, and operational author-side dossiers complete; these are not peer review |
| P1 manuscript | internally accepted | 40-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 3 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes |
| P2 manuscript | internally accepted | 47-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; query compiler, connectors, native-plan capture, hot-path trace, and performance evidence remain absent |
| P3 manuscript | internally accepted | 31-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; migration executor, loss detector, diff engine, backend runner, and performance evidence remain absent |
| P4 manuscript | internally accepted | 39-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; integration operator, factorization checker, connectors, identity resolver, and repair-surface experiment remain absent |
| P5 manuscript | internally accepted | 42-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 3 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; federation runtime and experiments remain absent |
| P6 manuscript | internally accepted | 36-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; incremental runtime, connector, equivalence result, crash/recovery result, provenance result, and benchmark remain absent |
| P7 manuscript | internally accepted | 36-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; identity runtime, fixtures, cross-language oracle, formal theorem, privacy/security result, and benchmark remain absent |
| P8 manuscript | internally accepted | 45-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; write-back runtime, proofs, and experiments remain absent |
| P9 manuscript | internally accepted | 49-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; workspace runtime, proofs, and experiments remain absent |
| P10 manuscript | internally accepted | 38-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; distributed runtime, recovery harness, proofs, and experiments remain absent |
| P11 manuscript | internally accepted | 43-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; consistency runtime, histories, convergence, recovery, and performance evidence remain absent |
| P12 manuscript | internally accepted | 40-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; sharding runtime, exchange executor, routing certificates, vector/full-text experiments, and distributed benchmarks remain absent |
| P13 manuscript | internally accepted | 36-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; provenance runtime, completeness, security, theorem, exporter, and benchmark evidence remain absent |
| P14 manuscript | internally accepted | 36-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; optimizer, calibration, global-optimality, scale, and benchmark evidence remain absent |
| P15 manuscript | internally accepted | 29-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; accepted Slice 4 has six Rust crates, 33 fixtures, 29 semantic outcomes, 4 structural outcomes, and zero Rust/Haskell disagreements; Slice 5 and production-runtime claims are excluded |
| P16 manuscript | internally accepted | 23-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 2 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; accepted Slice 2 has 16 semantic outcomes, 8 structural outcomes, 7 properties, and 1,550 trials; Slice 5 remains unreviewed |
| P17 manuscript | internally accepted | 30-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; fresh Lean 4.32.1 build, nine no-axiom reports, and 19 utility tests pass; instances, migration, queries, runtime refinement, backends, and distribution remain unverified |
| P18 manuscript | internally accepted | 28-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; `apps/mdreader/` remains empty and all application, accessibility, security, user-study, and performance evidence remains absent |
| Synthesis manuscript | internally accepted | 38-page exact-digest build; 300-DPI cover; AGY round 1 and canonical review end in `VERDICT: ACCEPT`; final verifier passes; all 18 component papers are represented at their accepted evidence boundaries and unreleased Slice 5 work is excluded |
| Shared fixture Slice 0 | internally accepted | validators, negative gate tests, and terminal Claude review pass |
| Rust semantic Slice 1 | internally accepted | 16 semantic-operation passes, 8 structural-only cases, all quality gates, and terminal Claude review pass |
| Haskell reference Slice 2 | internally accepted | 16 independent semantic outcomes, 8 structural-only outcomes, zero disagreements, deterministic properties, and terminal Claude review pass |
| Lean theorem Slice 3 | internally accepted | pinned build, axiom/source audits, 19 Python tests, and terminal Claude review pass for PATH-02..04 and MAP-03..05 only |
| Finite instance and bounded Delta Slice 4 | internally accepted | 29 semantic and 4 structural-only cross-language outcomes over 33 fixtures; terminal Claude review passes; unfixtured diagnostic-order divergences remain recorded |
| Conservative loss and schema diff Slice 5 | internally accepted | exact source commit `87f1df0`; 43 Rust and Haskell semantic outcomes, zero disagreements, 1,600 loss trials, 200 diff/apply trials, exact 26-record source closure, and terminal Claude Opus plus Codex security reviews pass; computational evidence only |
| Research-program implementation boundary | internally accepted | executable evidence ends at Slice 5; Slices 6--14 are deferred future engineering and are not completion blockers |
| Benchmark execution | blocked | intentionally deferred; the accepted deliverable is the protocol and falsification plan, with no harness, datasets, measured runs, or numerical results |
| MDReader application | blocked | intentionally deferred; P18 and the implementation-entry contract are research/design artifacts, while `apps/mdreader/` remains empty |
| P6 research dossier | internally accepted | author-side evidence contract complete; runtime, formal, crash-recovery, and benchmark claims remain `OPEN` or `OBSTRUCTED`; not paper peer review |

These Phase 2 statuses record internal planning QA, not paper peer review.
Domain, database-systems, adversarial, code, reproducibility, human-readable,
AGY, and Claude reviews remain reserved for their later paper/code phases.

Allowed statuses:

- `unreviewed`
- `under review`
- `major revision`
- `minor revision`
- `conditionally accepted`
- `internally accepted`
- `blocked`